News Summary – TIP, Cisco, CES and more

TIP Webinar
A re-run of the first Telepresence Interoperability Protocol webinar will be held today (27 JAN) at 10:00am eastern (GTM-5).
For Login details/info – Please mail tip_infor@imtc.org.

Vidyo @ CES 2011
Vidyo continues with it’s Home video-conferencing vision and shows HD multipoint video-conference between an iPad, iPhone 4, Samsung Galaxy Tab, Nexus S and a Mac.
Vidyo solutions aimed to bring video-conferencing anywhere – Interoperability between Telepresence/HDVC systems to mobile devices can benefit remote home workers for example.
It’s interesting to note that Cisco Umi, which is a great enabler for home Telepresence (at least on the technology/affordability aspect) – still can’t inter-op with Cisco’s professional video-conferencing/Telepresence equipment.
The different approaches to the term “Home Telepresence” are indeed interesting.


Vidyo Videoconferecing demonstation @ CES 2011


FaceFlow – In-browser Group Conferencing
TMCnet recently posted an article about “FaceFlow”, a small startup by a 21 years old Canadian student named Dany Pelletier.
FaceFlow (with a name non-surprisingly similar to Apple’s Facetime) leverage the Flash Player 10.1 support for RTMFP Groups and enable 3 user free video group calling straight from your browser.

Cisco Cius tablet to go live with Verizon 4G service
Mike Dolan from FierceVoIP reports that Cisco Cius will be launching on Verizon network in Spring 2011. Verizon 4G network was recently launched at December 2010 and is expected for nationwide coverage by 2013.

VoLTE ready (Based on VoLGA) Providers
In the great blog WirelessMoves by Martin Sauter, Martin talks about one entrance berrier for LTE smartphones and that’s VoLTE availability.

Cisco Reinventing TV?
CES 2011 brought us many innovations, one of them is the Cisco Videoscape – what Cisco calls “A service provider solution” for the future of the TV. Cisco Videoscape is a delivery platform for service providers and a set-top box for the consumers.
Cisco hopes to attract ISPs with both hardware/software solutions: Videoscape Media Suite and the Cisco Conductor for Videoscape and the consumer soltutions: The Videoscape media gateway, Videoscape IP set-top box and Videscape software clients.
Videoscape is Cisco’s attempt of unifying video consumption at home – making it simple and accessible. At the heart of the system is the media gateway – it will function as a routing and multimedia device and allow the consumer to watch Video and Web content on any connected network device (TV, PC, mobile device). Read More at our Videoscape Post.

About the writer: Itzhak Wolkowicz

Cisco – Reinventing TV?

Cisco Reinventing TV?
CES 2011 brought us many innovations; one of them is the Cisco Videoscape – A “service provider solution” for the future of the TV.


Cisco Videoscape
is a delivery platform for service providers and a set-top box/media gateway for the consumers.
Cisco hopes to attract service providers with both hardware/software solutions:
Videoscape Media Suite and the Cisco Conductor for Videoscape and the consumer solutions: The Videoscape media gateway, Videoscape IP set-top box and Videscape software clients.
The goal is to unify video consumption at home – making it simple and accessible. At the heart of the system is the media gateway – it will function as a routing and multimedia device and  allow the consumer to watch Video and Web content on any connected network device (TV, PC, mobile device). TV connectivity will be done with the set-top box, and Videoscape will also support Umi – Cisco’s Home Telepresence system.
When it comes to set-top IPTV boxes, it seems that Cisco is entering quite a crowded market – However its sheer marketing power and a complete product range might just do the trick.

But what makes it differ from current offerings by competitors (Google TV for example)?
1) It’s a complete platform (Media gateway AND a TV set-top box).
2) Unlike Google, Cisco is aiming for the ISPs – and maybe, unlike Google, they are more of a pipe rather than a potential threat to the Service/Content Providers themselves.

It’s pretty obvious that the key to the success of Videscape is the business benefits it will bring the service providers – Cisco talks about targeted ads, currently not available with today’s TV broadcasts.
By placing interactive web content next to TV streams and targeting specific audience Videoscape can help bring additional benefits to the current market.
As service providers relay on the “old” TV model and traditional media advertising - Videoscape success depends somehow on the decline of the traditional TV business, and that might take some time.

It seems  that the latest batch of Cisco products are driven by a long term strategy, as the increased traffic by video products can also boost networking products  - a major market for Cisco.
Increased adoption of video-centric consumer devices will boost online traffic, Cisco estimates that Global IP traffic will quadruple from 2009 to 2014 – and Video playing a major part in it.
Videoscape joins the lines of Cisco Umi and the recently acquired Flip cameras for yet an additional move into the home-video market.
While “reinventing TV” seems like a bold statement, things does look interesting for Cisco and the IPTV market as a whole.

About the writer: Itzhak Wolkowicz

Telepresence Interoperability Protocol Webinar

Update – TIP Webinar was a success – thanks for everyone who participated!
For more information about Telepresence Interoperability, check our TIP Page.

Earlier this year Cisco & Tandberg made headlines by demonstrating industry’s first immersive multi-screen Interoperability using Telepresence Interoperability Protocol (TIP).
In September of this year, IMTC took ownership for TIP and has established a new Activity Group.
The TIP AG  is responsible for the ongoing development of the TIP specification, TIP open source project management, and related development of interoperability tests between TIP adopters.
The TIP Activity Group is co-chaired by representatives from Polycom, AT&T & Cisco and has many members from companies in IMTC today.

IMTC will host a kick off Webinar on December 8, 2010 at 10 AM EST. This webinar will be a brief glimpse into the TIP Activity group and its vision. The webinar is free and open to all.

Please pre-register and access the TIP webinar from the following Webex link: https://ciscosales.webex.com/ciscosales/onstage/g.php?d=206589063&t=a

After the kickoff the Activity Group will have periodic, online meetings to steer the development of TIP. The group will also hold occasional face to face meetings as well as participate in multi-vendor test events, such as IMTC’s SuperOp.

TIP AG is an opportunity for your organization to participate in development of Telepresence Interoperability and leverage the benefits to offer Interoperable products and services.
For more information and inquiries, please contact us via mail at tip_infor@imtc.org
Membership to TIP AG is open only to IMTC members. To become a member of the IMTC and the TIP AG, please visit http://imtc.org/membership/join.asp

TIP Webinar Agenda December 8, 2010 10:00AM EST

  • 10:00 -10:10 Minutes IMTC Intro (Anatoli Levin, President IMTC)
  • 10:10 -10:30 Minutes TIP Overview (David Benham, Co-Chair TIP Activity Group)
  • 10:30 -10:35 Call for Membership (Louise Olson & Sumit Kumar, Co-Chairs TIP Activity Group)
  • 10:35-10:45 Q&A
IMTC TIP Introduction 

View more presentations from IMTC.


About the writer: Itzhak Wolkowicz

Telepresence Buzz – A week in Telepresence Marketing

Who is the leader of online Telepresence mind-share?

Telepresence isn’t new, the term dates back to the 80’s and the fundamental technology behind it isn’t new either.
The widespread usage of the term, however, is clearly new.
Only in the last few years Telepresence became popular in mainstream media:
This is partly to the fact that major players in the video-conferencing world offers Telepresence solutions, but much more importantly – it’s a direct result of marketing efforts made by them.
But who exactly leads this Telepresence revolution, and who own the digital marketing of the Telepresence industry?

The Contenders

Cisco - One of the world leaders in Networking, Data-Center and Consumer electronics. Cisco Telepresence line introduced in 2006, offers complete room solution with future interoperability through the TIP protocol.
Tandberg - A well established company with video-conferencing products dates back to the 90’s. Tandberg released their Telepresence solution in 2007 and was acquired by Cisco in 2009.
HPOne of the worlds largest IT companies – manufacturer of PC, Printers, Digital cameras, Servers, Software solutions and more – HP “Halo” studio considered one of the first Telepresence solutions and differs from competition by providing not only the hardware, but also the network infrastructure. This makes Halo an expensive (but also very reliable) product.
PolycomA manufacturer of Video-Conferencing and Audio products, Polycom introduced it’s RPX Telepresence line in 2006.
TelirisA privately owned company specialized in Telepresence equipment. Teliris delopyed it’s first telepresence solution back in 2001.
DVEA privately owned company specialized in video-conferencing solutions and known for it’s 3D Telepresence solution – The DVE Immersion Room.
DVE’s first HD telepresence solution dates back to 1999!
BrightcomEstablished in 2005, Brightcom manafucture HD & SD Telepresence and Video-conferencing solutions. Brightcom offers its Lumina Telepresence system with screens up to 85inch size.

Results

In this post we are talking about Telepresence Buzz, and how the buzz helps defining the market.
Our “Buzz” rating is based on weekly mentions in online media:
We checked how many times the word Telepresence was mentioned next to each brand to see which Telepresence products are being mentioned over the Internet and how many times. These are the statistics from the the beginning of November (01/11/10 – 07/11/10). We will continue checking these results to see how does new product lines and PR announcements effect each company web-presence.
Not mentioned in this report are Magor and TelepresenceTech, they will be examined however in later articles.

Source: Viralheat.com

First Place – 525 Weekly mentions – Cisco
Cisco knows how to market their products very well and actively seeking to make the word Telepresence known in every household.
The company used descriptive naming and named its Telepresence line -“TelePresence”.
Today, It’s no secret that when people think of Telepresence, Cisco is usually the first name that  comes to mind.
Cisco invests a lot of money in using Telepresence systems for humanitarian aid, distance learning and Telemedicine – They even use Telepresence to broadcast live music events.
The main spotlight for the TelePresence brand however is Television – From CNN to TV series like “24” and “30 Rock”, Cisco’s TelePresece is everywhere.
On the online front, other than maintaining an active telepresence blog, Cisco introduced a Telepresence calculator to help costumers to understand its ROI.
And to set things into proportions – The term “Cisco Telepresence Calculator” itself, is more popular on Google than “Tandberg Telepresence”, for example.
This month, with the announcement of Umi, Cisco made another big step to promote their Telepresence brand.
Umi, which is a home video-conferencing device, was named “Home Telepresence” – It’s safe to assume that Cisco will continue to make efforts to take ownership of the home Telepresence concept – out of the 33,300 Google results for “Home Telepresence”, only 517 does not mention Cisco.
One can say that Cisco tries to own the name “TelePresence” , and thus promote it’s Telepresence brand to the same status as “Coca Cola” or “Rollerblades”.
For now, that works well.

Second Place – 33 Weekly mentions – Polycom
Polycom was once considered the main rival for Tandberg in the Telepresence field, but after Tandberg was acquired by Cisco the situation changed a bit and in order to compete in this new situation Polycom chose to partner with multiple companies such as Microsoft and Juniper. Polycom partnerships create a strong web presence, their name was mentioned multiple times this week in regards to the IBM Unified Communications integration. It seems that the only company that can possibly create as much buzz as Cisco is Polycom, with the help of their business partners.

Third Place – 11 Weekly mentions – Tandberg
Tandberg is now a part of Cisco but they still maintain a web-presence of their own. Tandberg Telepresence products has been recently demonstrated to support TIP and that PR announcement had the most mentions of the Tandberg brand.

The Rest -

HP was one of the first big companies to offer a Telepresence solution and a managed network infrastructure, however it seems that nobody knows about it – or that nobody cares.
While Cisco put product placements at 24, 30 Rock and CSI – HP clearly isn’t a Buzzmaker.
The last PR I’ve read and relates to HP Telepresence was HP partnership with Vidyo to extend it’s visual communications to the desktop level.

BrightCom isn’t as big as the previous companies mentioned, as it’s a privately owned company dealing exclusively with Video-Conferencing and Telepresence.

Teliris and DVE are among the first to deploy Telepresence systems. Both companies are innovative, both offers 3D telepresence solution and both are generally absent from web mentions.

What can we learn from the results?

It’s quite clear that Cisco activly trying to appropriate Telepresence for itself. They began with the use of the term “TelePresence” as their product name and continue with naming Umi as “Home Telpresence”.
Cisco products appear in TV series like 24, CSI, NCIS and 30 Rock – When Telepresence being mentioned in a TV show, it’s probably Cisco’s.
This amount of commitment is absent from industry giants like HP. Budget wise it’s probably not even possible for the smaller competitors – Where does that leave anyone other than Cisco? This is the battle for the Internet, and when Marc Trachtenberg has to explain that he is the “CEO and co-founder of the company that installed the first telepresence solution for business use. Before you even think it – NOOOOO Cisco did NOT start the telepresence industry” – It’s not an easy battle.

In the next posts we’ll examine the Internet footprint of each of the key players, Stay tuned.

To return to IMTC blog, please press here.
About the writer: Itzhak Wolkowicz

Home Telepresence Report

Home Telepresence – What’s all the fuss?
Telepresence, as stated in our “What is Telepresence” post, is all about an immersive experience. And while video-conferencing isn’t new, creating an immersive experience is rather expensive and until today was out of the reach of the home user.

A typical environment for Telepresence Solutions

As the market moves to high-definition TV displays, broadband Internet speeds and powerful computer devices – creating this experience cheaply at home finally becomes a reality.

The term “Home Telepresence” is new, and was coined de-facto by the first one to introduce a high-quality video conferencing device aimed specifically for the home user – Cisco.

Home Telepresence by Cisco

Home Telepresence Options:
Today Cisco announced its home Telepresence product - ūmi (Pronounced yoo-me). ūmi is a pan-tilt camera that sits on top of the HDTV and set-top box system that connects to the television with a HDMI cable and allows for 1080P video conferencing.
Earlier in its CES demonstration, Cisco CEO John Chambers said that Cisco approach is device agnostic -
This hints that we might see Umi connectivity to other devices in the future. Cisco will charge 599$ for the hardware and a monthly subscription fee of 24.99$.
ūmi will ship at November 11th and is available for pre-order, Verizon will be the first to offer it to FiOS customers in 2011 although pricing details are unknown yet.

If Cisco’s Home Telepresence technology is indeed device agnostic, we might turn up to see it at running on devices like the Cisco Cius and maybe even on the new BlackBerry PlayBook (which includes a front-facing camera). Cisco said it’s looking into Facetime integration as well but it’s remains to be seen if Skype interoperability, a thing many consumers might be interested in, will actually happen. It’s worth mentioning that Skype just recently appointed Cisco’s head of enterprise, commercial and SMB unit as their CEO – and are looking for ways to expand. Recent TV models by major manufactures like Samsung and Panasonic are Skype enabled and allow for a Video Calling, although not in the same quality as the Cisco Umi or corporate video-conferencing systems.

The second big announcement made today, was by Logitech -
Logitech (Which bought LifeSize, a Telepresence company back in 2009) announced its Logitech Revue.
The Revue is a 299$, multi-purpose multimedia device based on the Google TV platform.
Revue offers movies, surfing abilities, and since it’s based on the Android platform – Adobe Flash and custom applications support.
Coming from Logitech, it’s almost no-brainer that they also added a video-conferencing capability in it with the addition of a 149$ camera called Logitech TV Cam.
At 448$ Total with the Revue itself – It’s not a cheap way of home video conferencing, but it’s a living-room experience and that’s different than using a software client on a desktop computer.

Is Home Telepresence really needed?
Both Revue and Umi are somewhat of a premium form of home video-conferencing as they require two things – buying a new device (unlike, using skype on a common laptop, for example) and a high speed broadband connection – The Revue use 1mbps (both upload and download) for 720P conferencing, and the Umi use 1.5mbps for 720P and 3.5mbps for 1080P. The bandwidth requirements makes the Home Telepresence solutions quite exclusive, and the Umialso requires a subscription fee of 25$ a month in addition to that – a 300$ yearly extra over the device cost itself. Will consumers be willing to pay the extra 149$ over the base price of the Revue or the more expensive costs of the Cisco Umi?

From our experience with Telepresence – seeing is believing.
The Home Telepresence experience is undoubtedly better than using a laptop with a software client but unless people get to actually see how good it is – the adaptation rate might be slow.

Can Home Telepresence win over cheaper video-chatting solutions?
For that to happen, some sort of a glue is needed. Many look at Apple as a possible “savior”, by opening a protocol such as Facetime, thus promoting unified communication between all sort of video enabled devices – Tablets, Cellular Phones, Set-Top boxes and professional Telepresence equipment. By creating a world of products that speaks in the same language, and enabling communication withmobile devices, users might see the overall benefit of living “inside” that eco-system.

So now more than ever, it make sense to ask – Apple, where are you?

About the writer: Itzhak Wolkowicz